Up until recently, and for good reason, being an Ideas Guy was largely worthless.
Sorry, that sounds a bit harsh. Let me clarify a bit:
Anyone can have an idea. Even a good idea. This means that ideas are plentiful. A dime a dozen, to use the popular idiom. It’s been the case up to this point, then, that being the guy with a good idea meant that you essentially had nothing. You had a passing fancy, a random shower thought, with little or nothing to back it up.
In a very real way, we’re all Ideas Guys some of the time. If you’ve ever been playing a video game and thought something along the lines of “You know, if we took element A from X game, element B from Y game, and element C from Z game, and mashed them all together, it would be Game of the Year for sure.” You’ve been an Ideas Guy. If you’ve used a product and really wished it had some specific feature that would make it easier for you to use (and especially if you then, however facetiously, waxed entrepreneurial about patenting that idea and making a ton of money), you’ve been an Ideas Guy, too. Sure, you probably never had any intention, let alone the requisite experience or industry connections, to put your idea into action and bring it to fruition, but that’s precisely the point I’m getting at here.
What separated Ideas Guys from the Product Designers, Engineers, Artists, Programmers or what have you that they (however temporarily) fancied themselves as was the skill set and follow-through to actually make or do those things, or at least the money to pay someone to do them for you.
This, then, became somewhat of a self-filtering system. The ideas that became actualized were only those that were solid enough that they inspired their respective conceptualizers to actually make good on realizing them. Be that by convincing them to pick up a skill set, to spend (or raise) an inordinate amount of money funding their creation, or more recently taking the time and effort to organize a crowdfunding campaign to have them made into a real product, with all the myriad headaches that entails. In other words, an idea had to be good enough to convince you to put some work in.
Now, however, there’s a growing technology (well, technically a number of closely related technologies) that are already changing just what an Ideas Guy is capable of. We’ve taken to calling this collection of technologies “AI.” It’s pretty obscure, you probably haven’t heard of it.
These days (and increasingly so with each passing day, it seems) AI is poised to usher in an era where nearly anything an Ideas Guy comes up with can be realized with a rapidly-diminishing amount of effort, at least in the digital realm. This leaves me with what could best be described as mixed feelings.
On the one hand, this lower barrier of entry to content creation means that a lot of things that would otherwise never see the light of day will actually be made, and that’s cool, because I’m sure there are more than a few good ideas which have never been made simply because the people who came up with them just didn’t have the time, skill, money or what-have-you to realize them. I certainly know more than well enough how it feels to lack the skill to realize an idea because you chose to dedicate your time and effort to a different skill set (as do many of us, I suspect). On the other hand, however, this lower barrier of entry to content creation also means that a lot of things that would otherwise never see the light of day will actually be made, and that’s not so good, because I’m sure there are more than a few ideas that are probably better left un-realized. Do we not have enough poor quality software already? Enough copycats and clones? Enough shovelware utilities that serve little other purpose than to frustrate us by barely functioning, or in the worst case, create unnecessary vulnerabilities in our commonly-used software? (I’m looking at you, Windows Notepad). Even before the advent of AI, we already see a ton of what could best be described as “slop” both digital and physical: Cheap, half-baked products churned-out en-masse, most of which could barely be described as functional. All this when doing these things still requires real effort. When you buy a new PC and it comes with a bunch of unnecessary utilities that serve no other real purpose than to be immediately uninstalled, those things required someone to be paid to create them. How bad then will it be when creating those things is cheaper and easier than ever?
More than this though, while I’m elated that we’ll likely see a lot of really cool things made by Ideas Guys that asked AI to create their ideas for them, I’m also saddened, because in exchange we’re in a large part handing over an era where most things were created with more thoughtful intent. Even the things that kind of sucked were, at least, not created as merely a passing fancy for the most part. Real people had to dedicate time, money, and effort creating them. It seems then that in much the same way that today some of us middle-aged folks wax poetic about the early 2000s when, despite the technology of today being undeniably more powerful, easier to use, and (mostly) cheaper, the technology then was at the very least more exciting, more experimental, and altogether more interesting, we’ll see an era in the not-too-distant future when the younger folks of today wax poetic about when software and games were created with more intent, more effort, and by people who spent years, decades perhaps, learning to create it.
This isn’t to say such things will disappear entirely, of course. We do even today, after all, see the occasional product that hearkens back to that interesting age when companies were throwing everything at the wall to see what stuck. It’s more that such things will become fewer and farther between, and I do feel that it’ll be sad to witness the awe people might have at a new piece of software or game that was lovingly crafted entirely by hand, with no AI assistance.
The future then, like always, looks unpredictable. About the only thing one can say about it for certain is that whatever we think it will look like, we’re probably incorrect. I intentionally don’t want to seem gloomy about the prospects of AI, and I do genuinely think it will give us some good things, teething issues notwithstanding. I have to believe that the fearmongering around datacenters, power infrastructure, and water use will prove largely unfounded. Not because they don’t exist now, they certainly do, but that we’ll perhaps find some way to condense models to a point where such datacenters are no longer necessary to do what we need them for today, and we’ll see hardware supply chains calm back down with things being done locally rather than in a giant building full of compute. History seems to suggest that that would be the case eventually, and it’s about as good a predictor of the future as we’ll likely ever have. Whatever the case may be, I’m certainly curious to see where the future will take us.